Named one of the Best Scholarly Books of 2022
The Chronicle of Higher Education
David Kurnick's account of <i>The Savage Detectives</i> shows a glittering intelligence at work. His writing is fluent; his analysis, sharp; his engagement, passionate. His account of the politics of the book and its reception is clear-eyed and wise. His close reading of the text and his insights into its complex form give real pleasure and will delight those who love this novel and enlighten those who are coming to it for the first time.
- Colm Tóibín, author of <i>Brooklyn: A Novel</i>,
Kurnick truly loves <i>The Savage Detectives</i>, and his affection for its poet-protagonists and their fellow-adventurers mirrors the visionary empathy of Bolaño’s most personal novel. Reading <i>The Savage Detectives</i> in Kurnick's company is like sitting down for a long conversation with a brilliant friend (mezcal optional)—an exhilarating mix of shared recognition and initiation into the fresh mysteries of Bolaño’s universe.
- Natasha Wimmer, translator of Roberto Bolaño’s <i>The Savage Detectives</i>,
The vividness of David Kurnick's critique somehow matches, and extends, the vividness of <i>The</i> <i>Savage Detectives</i> itself. His contextualizations, and the keenness of his perception, both open and anchor the book in new ways. A masterful reading that takes us well beyond any shallow fascinations of the Bolaño myth to a place of deeper appreciation.
- Justin Torres, author of <i>We the Animals</i>,
How to read <i>The Savage Detectives</i> anew? By providing a fresh, comprehensive, and detailed close reading that engages with the specificities of the book’s tantalizing idiosyncrasies without pandering to reductionist critical stances. Kurnick vindicates enthusiasm as a critical point of departure, a methodology almost, without succumbing to hagiography or fandom.
- -Héctor Hoyos, author of <i>Beyond Bolaño: The Global Latin American Novel</i>,
A warm and patient critical revaluation of Bolaño’s novel . . . By attending closely to technical detail, Kurnick demonstrates the power of careful analysis to cut through mythmaking; by countering sloppy interpretations of <i>The Savage Detectives </i>with a thoughtful, historically conscious one, he demonstrates the importance of criticizing with one’s own background and biases in mind. In so doing, he provides an example of the power of criticism: At its best, it can cut through embarrassment and bad faith to give readers a clearer view of a writer’s world.
- Lily Meyer, The Nation
Thrilling. <i>The Savage Detectives Reread</i> is not so much a readers’ guide as a sharp, playful, deeply poignant companion piece.
- Josh Weeks, Times Literary Supplement
Incandescent . . . It’s a work of living, electric, palpably humane literary theory.
- Anahid Nersessian, The Chronicle of Higher Education
[This book’s] meaningful contribution to Latin American literary studies is to analyze Bolaño from the outside: outside of the commercial fetish with world literature and the critical fetish with challenging it. Ultimately, the joy of reading Kurnick’s book is that, unlike a sizeable portion of today’s literary criticism, it never forgets its object of study.
- Bécquer Seguín, Critical Inquiry