This demanding, well-supported, and carefully documented argument requires very attentive reading. Recommended.
CHOICE
Raises some interesting issues regarding the conceptualization of freedom of the press.
Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
Splichal offers an insightful and richly illustrated historical account of modern-day understandings of press freedom and responsibility by tracing the liberal democratic ideal of news media as 'public watchdogs' and Habermas' ideal of news media as 'public forums' back to Jeremy Bentham's and Immanuel Kant's radically different conceptions of publicity.
Journal of Communication
Slavko Splichal's book is a thorough and brilliant rethinking, from philosophical and historical perspectives, of the basic meanings of press freedoms: why we have them, where we got them, and how they have been captured, redefined, and—in some cases—twisted in a modern Orwellian mode.
- Monroe Price, Oxford University,