Ashton is clearly one of the more readable modern biblical scholars. His analogies from literature (classical and modern), music, history, philosophy, as well as his own ability to turn a clever phrase, enable Ashton to merge refreshing style with careful analysis. The result is a book that, with some flaws, is literate, insightful and critical.
There is much in this book to appeal to more traditional scholars of the fourth gospel ... there is some admirable diachronic scholarship in Studying John.
Expository Times
Stimulating ... beautifully written.
Theology
No superficial judge, the author proposes thoughtful alternatives to any position he deems seriously flawed ... This present collection of essays and extensive bibliography is tough and serious fare, appropriate to the scholar, teacher, and scholarly pastor.
Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society
Ashton clearly is one of the more readable of modern biblical scholars. His analogies from literature (classical and modern), music, history, philosophy, as well as his own ability to turn a clever phrase, enable Ashton to merge refreshing style with careful analysis. The result is a book that, with some flaws, is literate, insightful, and critical.
Journal of Religion
John Ashton ... rises to a spirited defense of historical criticism in his collection of eight essays on the Gospel of John.
The Cresset
He writes with clarity, scholarly breadth, and with sensitivity for a well-turned phrase ... There is something in his book for almost every Johannine scholar ... it could be used with profit as a reference tool and as a text in graduate seminars on John's Gospel.
Critical Review