Ferraresi and Goldbach have brought together scholars approaching syntactic reconstruction from different theoretical perspectives, and drawing data from various language families. The resulting collection mirrors the challenges and uncertainties in the ongoing debate. The volume, with such heterogeneity, marks a milestone and will be of interest to historical linguists and those interested in models of linguistic variation.

- Chiaro Gianollo, University of Konstanz, on Linguist List, Vol. 20.4367 (2009),

[...] a very useful survey of the current issues in syntactic reconstruction. It provides a balanced picture of the different approaches, their theoretical assumptions and methodologies, the challenges they face, the types of results they can achieve, as well as the questions, doubts and problems they raise [...]

- Katalin É. Kiss, Research Institute for Linguistics of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, in Diachronica Vol. 26:3 (2009).,

Linguists have long been fascinated with the question of whether and how one can reconstruct prehistoric systems. Possibilities depend on theories of variation, acquisition and change and on what one is aiming to reconstruct. Here is a well-conceived and very useful volume that explores a range of possibilities for syntax. The comparative perspective will advance our understanding of methods for reconstruction.

- David W. Lightfoot, Georgetown University,