"…exciting…complex…persuasive…full of new revelations…’it helps us to better comprehend Heaney and Walcott and offers us a richer, more contemporary Dante, a Dante who is alive…" – Valeria Tinkler-Villani, in: Incontri, Anno 20 (2005), pp. 194-199
"…it offers significantly new perspectives…, …important and thoroughly scholarly…, …an invaluable resource…" – Lyn Innes, in: New West Indian Guide, Vol. 78, No. 3-4 (2004), pp.351-353
"…based on sound, indeed impeccable scholarship" – Edward Baugh, in: Research in African Literatures, Vol. 34.1 (Spring 2003), pp. 151-9
"…illuminating, absorbing, engaging[…], [of] inestimable value to the scholar." – John Ennis, in: Agenda, Vol. 39.1-3 (Winter 2002-2003), pp.323-327
"…it is wonderful to see someone with deep knowledge and empathy restoring tous a sense of Dante as contemporary; [it] exposes the practice of much contemporary poetic criticism that tends to be parochial in time… [..] Part of the pleasure of this book is its clarity: close-reading and fine judgements…" – Archie Markham, in: Wasafiri, Vol. 38 (Spring 2003), pp. 69-71
"After reading this book, it is difficult indeed to believe that Heaney’s and Walcott’s dialogue with the medieval poet may have gone unremarked for so long. Fumagalli redresses this imbalance admirably" – Lucia Boldrini, in: New Comparison, Vol. 33-34 (Spring/Autumn 2002), pp.304-305
"…articulate and subtle analysis…" – Piero Boitani, in: La Domenica del Sole 24Ore (20 January 2002), p. 36