As Upamanyu Pablo Mukherjee argues in his insightful, well-researched Crime and Empire, the British campaigns against both sati and Thuggee were part of a more general reformist approach to India that at once mirrored the rise of the "new police" in Britain and had the effect of criminalizing Indian culture as a whole. And if secular, utilitarian reformism worked to criminalize India, that was just as true of evangelicalism, as Jeffrey Cox points out: "For evangelicals ... something was very wrong with India, and the source of the evil was crystal clear: it was religion. Hinduism was obscene and cruel and bloody and lascivious, and so forth, and because of Hinduism, Indians were liars, thieves, widow-burners, murderers of infants, and so forth"(24)...
...From the time of the Black Hole of Calcutta in 1757, Mukherjee contends, to that of the Indian Rebellion or Mutiny of 185758 and beyond, imperial discourse about India was mainly a "rhetoric of crime" and policing (15). And among the writers of crime fiction whom he analyzes, none is more significant than policeman Taylor.
Victorian Literature and Culture, 2006
Mukherjee's crimes and criminals reveal a remarkable agreement that in the novel as elsewhere, Justice is a far cry from Law.
Times Literary Supplement