Selected as an Outstanding AcademicTitle for 2007 by Choice Magazine "Most of the stuff one reads about opera is either hack or musicological maundering. With Bernard Williams you’re in touch with a subtle, well-furnished mind which visualizes opera as a cultural artefact with complex literary and philosophical implications. And yet at the same time the text is lucid, intelligible and diverting, without a trace of post-modernist jargon or structuralist bullshit."—Jonathan Miller ". . . a new standpoint and an unfamiliar kind of thinking . . . the writing is a delight."—Stanley Sadie"The most powerful of Bernard [William's] intellectual dispositions was his humanism: a great delight in what people can be, at the beauty of what they can make in music, art and ideas, at the rich varieties of culture they can imagine and live, but also an empathetic sense of people's limitations and failures, their humanity in the sense of weakness as well as achievement."—Ronald Dworkin"Music was deeply important to Bernard [Williams]. He did not just like it. He studies it, practised it, and wrote about it."—Sir Keith Thomas"His sheer appetite for life was wide in scope and varied in mode. He brought clarity of mind and gaiety of spirit to crucial issues of identity, justice, society, psychology, art and (particularly) music."—Reverend John Drury