The subjects covered are familiar enough but most readers will come across something new.
Geoffrey Best, Times Literary Supplement
Rose's meticulous footnotes make it an excellent vehicle for the more advanced student and scholar to follow up issues raised in the text and not only those concerning the Second World War.
Gill Sinclair, University of Kent
immensely impressive
Annual Bulletin of Historical Literature
More than a decade after its publication, Which People's War? remains a model for students interested in contemporary cultural history, as well as a salutary reminder of the implicit exclusions inherent in any nationalist project
Laura Beers, Reviews in History