The strengths of this book are its nuances, its marshalling of evidence and its subtle understanding of the problem of identity. There are numerous illuminating details of argument ... We learn a good deal about views of Troy beyond Athens, Alexander and Rome, which is refreshing and helpful, and Erskine's account of Rome's interest in Ilion itself is a textbook analysis of identity politics. This will be an interesting book for scholars, useful to students and accessible even to sixth formers.
The Journal of Classics Teaching
... wealth of fresh observation distilled into this illuminating book.
Journal of Roman Studies
Erskine refreshingly abandons any notion of the intrinsic significance of the myths ... the antiquarian-minded non-specialist will find much to enjoy in the bizarre local adaptations, and their articulation in a wide variety of archaeological and literary sources ... a refreshing demand to think again about how myths, particularly foundation myths, can do their work even against the most obvious demands of both rationality and tradition.
Matthew Fox, Times Literary Supplement
A detailed and spirited sifting of evidence.
Peter Stothard, Times Higher Education Supplement