'may well prove to be a landmark in the historiography of the subject . . . well-researched and cogently argued'
- Times Literary Supplement,
'[A] careful study . . . Semelin details, in accessible prose and with cogent organization, the extraordinarily complex story of Jews-French and foreign-in France during the Occupation.' -
‘Engagingly written, combining psychological perspectives with first-rate historical research, and brimming with original insights, this is masterful scholarship.’
- CHOICE,
'An altogether remarkable and indispensable book for all those with an interest in France and the Shoah.'
- Serge Klarsfeld,
'A most important book on the history of Jews in Vichy France. This meticulously researched work is already standard reading in the field and hugely contributes to the difficult debate on why 75% of Jews in France survived the Holocaust.'
- Jean-Marc Dreyfus,