[The book] is like a banquet, in which every dish is tempting ... This is a book every library and school should purchase
Rosemary Goring, Glasgow Herald
a splendid choice of contributors
Owen Dudley Edwards, Scottish Affairs
hugely impressive on a number of levels ... the contributors also provide thoughts and direction to drive future research,making this impressive work a living document and not just a passive account of the past ... a timely,approachable and professional look at Scotland in the modern era.
CHOICE USA
If you want to know about the latest thinking in Scottish history since 1500,this is where to start...characterised by the most formidable learning
TC Smout, Herald Books of the Year 2012
Without doubt,a milestone in pos-1500 Scottish history...absorbing with an impressive breadth of coverage
Journal of Scottish Historical Studies