This excellent study, long overdue, serves as a thorough introduction to the English Charlemagne texts and as a corrective to the common assumption that these works lack merit. . . . Highly recommended.
JOURNAL OF ENGLISH AND GERMANIC PHILOLOGY
An essential study for those interested in the Charlemagne legend.
FRANCIA
Carefully researched, ambitious in scope, and lucidly written, [the book] conclusively debunks long-held perceptions of the insular Charlemagne narratives as inferior `hack-work' and will become an indispensable resource for anyone working within this tradition.
REVIEW OF ENGLISH STUDIES
Hardman and Ailes have made an important contribution to this initiative by giving scholars a much-needed survey and study of insular Charlemagne literature.
SPECULUM
this book offers many new insights into the political and cultural uses of translation and adaptation, as well as a fresh perspective on the development of Middle English literature through dialogue with literature in French.
FRENCH STUDIES
[A] rich and deeply researched study that is carefully organized and refreshingly readable, especially given the depth and detail that it provides.
H-FRANCE REVIEW
Over recent years an increasing awareness of multilingualism in medieval England has been informing linguistic, literary, and cultural scholarship. This book, exploring the intersection of Anglo-Norman and Middle English literary production across religious, geographic, and socio-political contexts, is a solid piece of work sharing in this discourse.
PARERGON