'splendid book ... Life in the maquis, is brilliantly evoked'
Times LIterary Supplement
`a wealth of vivid particular incident which admirably conveys the strength of popular feeling against conscription, the misery which was so often the lot of conscripts and deserters alike, the brutality with which conscription was enforced and the resistance to it suppressed ... immensely readable.
History
'fascinating and important book ... Forrest constructs an admirably large canvas, combining broad strokes with a pointillism that reflects his sensitivity to individual human beings in concrete social environments ... Forrest has achieved a commendably balanced and suggestive synthesis'
Isser Woloch, Columbia University, Journal of Modern History, Volume 64, Number 2, June 1992