What makes Stephen Small's book particularly welcome is his concentration on political arguments and his attempt to trace the ideas of the 1790s back to the age of the American Revolution.
English Historical Review
The range of sources consulted, deployed and extensively quoted tells us much that we did not previously know.
English Historical Review
... as a sustained effort to engage with discourse 'in its own right' it marks a significant advance in the study of late eighteenth-century Ireland.
History
Insights are peppered throughout the book, along with excellent descriptions of individual pamphlets or pamphleteers. There is also much to admire in Dr Small's knowledge of the printed sources.
Eighteenth-Century Ireland
Dr Small's book is an indispensable addition to this discussion ... essential reading for anyone interesed in late eighteenth-century Ireland.
Eighteenth-Century Ireland
... a work that greatly enhances and expands understanding of eighteenth-century Irish patriotism and, to a lesser degree, of the origins of Irish republicanism. It is an impressive first book.
History of Political Thought
...an insightful, extremely careful and extraordinarily balanced study of one of the most crucial events in early modern Irish history.
Frederik Herzberg, Journal of the Oxford University History Society