The five volumes which make up Philosphy of Quine contain the most essential of the more than 2000 articles on this subject. Chosen for their clarity and brevity, they cover both basic ideas as well as objections written about Quine's work.

ONTOLOGICAL COMMENT Geach, Peter, On What There Is Part I, Aristotelian Society Supplementary vol 25 [1951] Ayer, Alfred J, On What There Is Part II, Aristotelian Society Supplementary vol 25 [1951] Black, Max, Comments on the Preceding Paper of W V Quine, Daedalus 80 [1951] Church, Alonzo, Symposium: Ontological Commitment, Journal of Philosophy 55 [1958] Scheffler, Israel and Noam Chomsky, What Is Said To Be, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 19 [1958-59] Grandy, Richard E, On What There Need Not Be, Journal of Philosophy 66 [1969] INDETERMINACY OF REFERENCE (ONTOLOGICAL RELATIVITY) Jubien, Michael, Two Kinds of Reduction, Journal of Philosophy 66 [1969] Stich, Stephen P, Dissonant Notes on the Theory of Reference, Nous 4 [1970] Field, Hartry, Theory Change and the Indeterminacy of Reference, Journal of Philosophy 70 [1973] Leeds, Stephen, How to Think About Reference, Journal of Philosophy 70 [1973] Morscher, Edgar, Ontology as a Normative Science, Journal of Philosophical Logic 3 [1974] Aune, Bruce, Quine on Translation and Reference, Philosophical Studies 27 [1975] Massey, Gerald, Indeterminacy, Inscrutability and Ontological Relativity, American Philosophical Quarterly 12 [1978] Davidson, Donald, The Inscrutability of Reference, Southwestern Journal of Philosophy 10 [1979] Putnam, Hilary, The Way the World Is, In Realism with a Human Face {Cambridge,Mass: Harvard University Press, 1990] TRUTH Field, Harry, Quine and the Correspondence Theory, Philosophical Review 83 [1974] Davidson, Donald, A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge, In Dieter Henrich, ed., Kant oder Hegel [Stuttgart: Klett-Cotta, 1983] Bergstrom, Lars, Quine's Truth, Inquiry 37 [1994] Quine, W V, Response to Bergstrom, Inquiry 37 [1994] Davidson, Donald, What is Quine's View of Truth?, Inquiry 37 [1994] Quine, W V, Response to Davidson, Inquiry 37 [1994] REALISM Kruger, Lorenz, Some Remarks on Realism and Scientific Revolutions, In Peter Bieri, Rolf Peter Horstmann and Lorenz Kruger, eds., Transcendental Arguments and Science [Dordrecht: Reidel, 1979] Hylton, Peter, Rorty and Quine on Scheme and Content, Philosophical Topics 25 [1997] NOMINALISM Mohanty, J N, A Note on Modern Nominalism, Philosophical Quarterly (India) 32 [1960] PHYSICALISM Schuldenfrei, Richard, Dualistic Physicalism in Quine: A Radical Critique, Philosophical Forum 10 [1978] Dreben, Burton, Putnam, Quine and the Facts, Philosophical Topics 20 [1992] Putnam, Hilary, Reply to Burton Dreben, Philosophical Topics 20 [1992] PROPOSITIONS I