The five volumes which make up Philosphy of Quine contain the most essential of the more than 2000 articles on this subject. Chosen for their clarity and brevity, they cover both basic ideas as well as objections written about Quine's work.

MODALITY Smullyan, A F, Modality and Description, Journal of Symbolic Logic 13 [1948] Myhill, John, Problems Arising in the Formalization of Intentional Logic, Logique et Analyse I [1958] Wilson, N L, Modality and Identity, Journal of Philosophy, 62 [1965] Sleigh, Robert,Jr, A Note on an Argument of Quine's, Philosophical Studies 17 [1966] Burge, Tyler, Kaplan, Quine and suspended Belief, Philosophical Studies 31 [1977] Church, Alonzo, A Remark concerning Quine's Paradox and Modality, In Nathan Salmon and Scott Soames, eds., Propositions and Attitudes [Oxford: Oxford University Press: 1988] SINGULAR TERMS Wilson, Neil L, Property Designation and Description, Philosophical Review 64 [1955] Strawson, P F, Singular Terms and Predication, Journal of Philosophy 58 [1961] Loar, Brian, Reference and Propositional Attitudes, Philosophical Review 81 [1972] Linsky, Leonard, Quine on Quantifying in, Journal of Philosophy 66 [1969] Hornsby, Jennifer, Singular Terms in Contexts of Propositional Attitude, Mind 86 [1977] IDENTITY Evans, Gareth, Identity and predication, Journal of Philosophy 72 [1975] PHILOSOPHY OF MATHEMATICS Parsons, Charles, Ontology and Mathematics, Philosophical Review 80 [1971] LOGIC Leblanc, Hughes, Commentary on W V Quine's Free Logic, description and Virtual Clases, Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review 36 [1977] SURPRISE EXAM Ayer, A J, On A Supposed Antinomy, Mind 82 [1973] Bennett, Johnathan, Review of Several Papers on the Surprise Exam, Journal of Symbolic Logic 30 [1965] NEW FOUNDATION (1937) Boffa, M, Sets Equipollent to their power set in NF, Journal of Symbolic Logic 40 [1975] Boffa, M, The Consistency Problem for NF, Journal of Symbolic Logic 42 [1977] Boffa, M, ZFJ and the Consistency Problem for NF, Jahrbuch der Kurt Goedel Gesselschaft [1988] Crabbe, M, On the Consistency of an Imprecicative Subsytem of Quine's NF, Journal of Symbolic Logic 47 [1982] Crabbe, M, The Hauptsatz for Stratified Comprehension: A Semantic Proof, Mathematical Logic Quarterly 40 [1994] Crabbe, M, On NFU, Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 33 [1992] Dzierzgowski, Daniel, Models of Intuitionistic TT and NF, Journal of Symbolic Logic 60 [1995] Forster, Thomas, Quine's NF 60 years on, American Mathematical Monthly 104 [November 1997] Forster, Thomas, Term Models for weak Set Theories with a Universal Set, Journal of Symbolic Logic 57 [1987] Forster, Thomas and Kaye, End extensions preserving power set, Journal of Symbolic Logic 56 [1991] Grishin, V N, Consistency of a Fragment of Quine's NF System