The five volumes which make up Philosphy of Quine contain the most essential of the more than 2000 articles on this subject. Chosen for their clarity and brevity, they cover both basic ideas as well as objections written about Quine's work.

Harman, Gilbert, Quine on Meaning and Existence I, Review of Metaphysics 21 [1967] Harman, Gilbert, Quine on Meaning and Existence II, Review of Metaphysics 21 [1967] Kirk, Robert, Quine's Interdeterminacy Thesis, Mind 78 [1969] Humphries, Barbara M, Indeterminacy of Translation and Theory, Journal of Philosophy 67 [1970] Rorty, Richard, Indeterminacy of Translation and of Truth, Synthese 23 [1972] Morton, Adam, Denying the Doctrine and Changing the Subject, Journal of Philosophy 70 [1973] Dummett, Michael, The Significance of Quine's Indeterminacy Theory, Synthese 27 [1974] Quine, W V, Comment on Michael Dummett, Synthese 27 [1974] Harman, Gilbert, Comment on Michael Dummett, Synthese 27 [1974] Parsons, Charles, On Translating Logic, Synthese 27 [1974] Dummett, Michael, Reply to W V Quine, Synthese 27 [1974] Friedman, Michael, Physicalism and the Indeterminacy of Translation, Nous 9 [1975] Gibson, Roger F, Are There Really Two Quines?, Erkenntnis 15 [1980] Hacking, Ian, Was There Ever A Radical Mistranslation?, Analysis 41 [1981] Hylton, Peter, Analyticity and the Interdeterminacy of Translation, Synthese 52 [1982] George, Alexander, Whence and Whither the Debate Between Quine and Chomsky, Journal of Philosophy 83 [1986] Chomsky, Noam, Replies to George's and Brody's Reviews of Knowledge of Language, Mind and Language 2 [1987] Searle, John R, Indeterminacy, Empiricism and the First Person, Journal of Philosophy 84 [1987] Chihara, Charles S, Quine's Indeterminacy In Juduth Jarvis Thomson, ed., On Being and Saying [Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press] Hylton, Peter, Translation, Meaning and Self-Knowledge, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Exegesis Philosophical Topics 20 [1992] Massey, Gerald J, The Indeterminacy of Translation: A Study in Philosophical Exegesis, Philosophical Topics 20 [1992]6L Putnam, Hilary, Reply to Gerald Massey, Philosophical Topics 20 [1992] Abel, Gunter, Indeterminacy and Interpretation, Inquiry 37 [1994] PRINCIPLE OF CHARITY Grandy, Richard, Reference, Meaning and Belief, Journal of Philosophy 70 [1973]