The contributions are all of a high standard. Problems are clearly defined, concepts clarified, fine distinctions drawn, objections considered, and supporting evidence purveyed. In their documentation, scrupulous attention to opposing arguments, integrity, and clarity of reasoning, the contributions are models of professional academic philosophy ... The many virtues of the analytical tradition are manifest in chapter after chapter ... This anthology merits close perusal by anyone interested in genuine film theory.
Trevor Whittock, Brit Jrnl of Aesthetics, Vol 39, no 3, 1999
Admirably edited by Allen and Smith, who contribute an excellent introductory chapter summing up the argument against the continentals ...
W. A. Vincent, Michigan State University, CHOICE sept 98, vol 36, no 2